The Fierce Convictions of Hannah More – a review of Karen Swallow Prior’s biography of a poet, reformer and abolitionist

A Consecrated Pen

In Fierce Convictions – The Extraordinary Life of Hannah More: Poet, Reformer, Abolitionist (2014, Thomas Nelson), Karen Swallow Prior presents the life of a woman described by John Newton as wielding “a consecrated pen.” One might be tempted to say that Prior wields the same pen in her account of this 18th-19th Century woman of letters, action and faith.

In fact, for More there would be no way to separate her pen from her actions, nor either of those from her faith. She pursued them all for the sake of serving the people God placed in her life – from her teen years organizing a local school with her four sisters to her later efforts to feed the poor, prevent animal cruelty, and abolish slavery throughout the British realms.

While she worked hard in serving others, all her efforts seem to have rested upon what she could do with words. From writing successful plays for the London stage to tracts produced inexpensively for the poor, from poetry to novels, there wasn’t a genre of writing that More did not attempt. And once attempted, there wasn’t a genre she did not master.

A Nondescript Origin

Prior’s description of Hannah More’s childhood reveals More’s early life to be nothing out of the ordinary. She was a bright child who benefitted greatly from her father being a school teacher, but the world is always populated by such children. Few of them rise to More’s level of influence and success.

Still, Prior’s work on More is no hagiography, as she explains the earliest biographies of More tended to be. There are triumphs and failures, with many personal shortcomings noted alongside many admirable qualities.

For example, More was generous to the poor, yet took pains to make sure she did nothing that might encourage the poor to rise above their station in life. She provided support for French Catholics fleeing the anti-religious violence of the French Revolution, but she refused to join those who would give British Catholics the right to hold political office. And she reached out to those below her rank in society as people of merit and whose company she cherished, while also chasing after connections with those above her own mid-level station in life.

A Varied Career

Fierce Convictions starts with More’s early years, and each chapter addresses various pursuits and causes. Prior keeps the story generally progressing toward the end of More’s life as we see that More took on some issues later than others. But there is much in her life that overlaps and the chapters cannot be taken as strictly moving ever forward.

This is one of the book’s main strengths, along with Prior’s ability to present her extensive research in a thoroughly readable fashion. Prior chose the subject of More’s literary influence for a scholarly treatment in her dissertation for her PhD, so a reader might fear that this biography is written in a way that no lay reader could access. Prior’s prose, however, is welcoming and well-crafted throughout. Readers who are new to Prior’s writing will be pleased while those who have read her 2012 literary memoir Booked – Literature in the Soul of Me will not be the least surprised.

We read of More starting a school that included boys and girls learning the same subjects, an untypical practice of the mid 1700s. More and her sisters wanted to counter the trend of “Frivolous education [which] created shallow women”, as Prior puts it. They were up against tough opposition, with Jean Jacques Rousseau’s treatise on education stating the prevailing view that “the whole education of  women ought to relate to men” (as quoted by Prior), and thus there was no subject a woman should bother learning except those that improved her ability to serve a man. More’s words and her actions showed she disagreed with that influential philosopher entirely.

Cheddar, Somerset, England - One of the school's More established

Cheddar, Somerset, England – One of the school’s More established

Much of the book returns to More’s education efforts. She helped establish schools for the poor and wrote educational tracts for the working class. Most of her works seemed to have been pedantic in nature, whether directed at education reforms in particular or the betterment of some other aspect of British society.

Prior describes the animal cruelty prevalent in popular entertainment at that time – bear baiting, bull running and cock fighting for instance – in order to set in sharp contrast More’s writings against the cruelty. More didn’t stop at writing, though, as she also called upon her wealthy friends and acquaintances to provide funds to support her efforts to sway public opinion and eventually change the law.

She also provided food for the poor, and not just from her own larder. When the economy suffered during the Napoleonic Wars and the laboring class was most affected, she raised funds and published pamphlets and herself brought food to nearby villages and towns in order to feed families.

Yet the cause she is most known for – if she is known for anything at all – is the abolition of slavery in the British realms.

Abolitionist

The abolition of slavery in England is often credited to William Wilberforce. He acted when many would not, but he did not act alone. He was aided by many friends and colleagues, including his close life-long friend Hannah More.

The chapters on abolition and the group of friends who gathered in a stately home of a friend in Clapham – then a village just southwest of London – come in the second half of this biography. One might have expected to read of this earlier, or at least hoped to get to the anticipated good parts more quickly. It would have been a shame.

In Prior’s hands, the life of Hannah More is presented just as it should be. By understanding More’s other efforts to live out her faith we better understand why and how her work on abolition came about and reached fruition. It’s not that the abolitionist work came after all the other work was completed. More’s life, remember, did not progress as linearly as a biography might suggest. Rather, while much was happening concurrently it is by learning of More herself through her actions that the abolition work is revealed most clearly. The decision to save this work for later in the book turns out to be Prior’s gift to the reader.

***

[I received a complimentary advance copy of the book from the publisher. I did not promise anything in return, and this review is based on what I think my readers might want to know about Prior’s book.

One thing that jumped off the pages is an interesting parallel between Hannah More’s life and the novels of Jane Austen, a contemporary of More’s. I explore this parallel in Jane Austen Novels and Hannah More’s Life – intersecting planes.]

***

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to The Fierce Convictions of Hannah More – a review of Karen Swallow Prior’s biography of a poet, reformer and abolitionist

  1. Jeannie says:

    I’ve heard so many accolades about this book already, and this review just adds to my sense that More is a woman we all should know more about! Thanks for your thoughtful review, Tim; I look forward to reading Karen’s book soon.

  2. Laura Droege says:

    Sounds like a fascinating book about a fascinating woman. Regarding those strange contradictions (such as support for Catholics in one sphere but not another), it seems to me that many people have such contradictions in their behaviors and beliefs; the stronger the personality, the stronger, more disturbing, and more deeply divisive these behaviors seem to be.

    • Tim says:

      Interesting insight on contradictions getting stronger with strength of personality, Laura. She was quite progressive on some matters, but hide-bound in others.

  3. Pastor Bob says:

    Looks promising, because:
    A good biography is good reading.
    Thanks!

  4. Aimee Byrd says:

    Putting this book on my wishlist, Tim. Sounds like a great book to give as a gift as well. I’m looking forward to your next post, sounds intriguing.

    • Tim says:

      I think you’ll enjoy it, Aimee. You might want to get a copy for Dana Tuttle too, since she has a penchant for reading about dead women of the faith.

      And speaking of Dana Tuttle, she has a guest post coming up here on Friday. It’s all about the Salem Witch Trials, and what better topic to post on October 31?

  5. Pingback: Jane Austen Novels and Hannah More’s Life – intersecting planes | Tim's Blog – Just One Train Wreck After Another

  6. KSP says:

    Thanks for the review, Tim! I’m glad you enjoyed the book and I hope some of your readers will as well. It’s a pleasure to be at your place again. KSP

  7. Pingback: Fierce Coffee Mugging | Tim's Blog – Just One Train Wreck After Another

Talk to me (or don't)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s